The Controversy Of Genetic Testing
Genetic testing for autism is a controversial topic for advocates of neurodiversity who argue that it increases misconceptions and discrimination. Some advocates within the disability rights community view autism as a natural form of beinga form of neurological diversity .
The notion that autism and other neurological conditions are a form of diversity is referred to as the neurodiversity paradigm. This paradigm focuses on the positive aspects of the condition. In the case of autism, for example, positive aspects might include the ability to focus on detail, and a high tolerance for repetition, etc. The argument posed by this paradigm is that society paints a picture of disability through the lens of neurotypical status and this leads to discrimination.
Genetic testing is largely criticized according to the neurodiversity paradigm for two key reasons. Firstly, it could aggravate societal discrimination . Secondly, funding allocated to genetic testing for autism could instead be allocated to improving the quality of life of those with autism and their families .
Other issues often raised around the concept of genetic testing for autism are: genetic discrimination, privacy concerns, the psychological burden on parents and families, and unequal access to genetic services.
From Finding The Right Clinician To Diagnostic Tools And Parent Interviews There Are Many Steps
An autism diagnosis covers a spectrum of children with a wide range of skills and impairments. Because of this, the developmental disorder can look very different from child to child. Many experts who diagnose and treat children with autism like to say, If youve seen one child with autism, youve seen one child with autism.
The diversity of autism spectrum disorder can make it difficult to correctly diagnose. Sometimes autistic children are mistakenly diagnosed with a different disorder, like ADHD, or are told that nothing is wrong. Other times kids are diagnosed as autistic when they actually arent.
Thats why its important for parents to know what the components of an autism diagnosis should be: What kinds of information should a clinician whos evaluating your child be considering? How can you know whether your clinician is following best practices in doing an autism assessment?
Autism Diagnosis: What To Expect
Theres no single test for autism. Instead, autism diagnosis is based on:
- watching how your child plays and interacts with others that is, how your child is developing now
- interviewing you
- reviewing your childs developmental history that is, how your child has developed in the past.
Diagnosis usually involves many specialists and professionals assessing your child this is called a multidisciplinary assessment. When many specialists work with your child, it gives your child the best chance of an accurate diagnosis. It also helps to develop the best plan for supporting your child.
A multidisciplinary team usually includes a paediatrician, a psychologist, a speech pathologist and sometimes a child psychiatrist. It might also include other professionals, like an occupational therapist.
The professionals might want to see you and your child several times. Theyll ask you questions about your childs current and past development and behaviour. Theyll measure your childs strengths and difficulties in areas like thinking, moving, socialising, communicating and so on. And theyll ask about or watch how your child interacts and plays with others.
You might meet with all the professionals on the same day, in the same place. Or you might see one professional at a time for example, you might see a paediatrician first and then a speech pathologist or psychologist first at a later time.
Read Also: James Holzhauer Autistic
How Do Doctors Diagnose Autism
Autism is one of the more prevalent disorders with which children are currently diagnosed. According to the statistics, 1 in 54 children born in the United States is now diagnosed with autism. Broadly speaking, the numbers have increased dramatically over the past few decades. Much of this increase has been attributable to an increase in autism test and screening. This, of course, leads to a very important question: How do doctors diagnose autism?
Early Detection Early Intervention
It is comforting to believe that ASD prenatal testing is mostly about helping scientists discover more about genetic variations linked to autism, and identifying autism at the earliest opportunity to allow parents to plan ahead. The argument is convincing when you consider studies examining the effect of early autism intervention, especially with regards to brain plasticity . In this study, the authors concluded that early intervention enhancing social attention, should lead to alterations in brain activity.
A prenatal test detecting autism in a fetus could provide parents with enough time to shift expectations, appeal for all the support theyll need, and prepare themselves emotionally and financially. But preparing for a life of care will also bring up the inevitable question for some parents of whether it would be easier not to embark on the journey at all.
Looking at a study about the estimation of people with Down syndrome in Europe, a reduction of 27% was estimated, meaning approximately 417 000 people with Down Syndrome were living in Europebut without elective abortions there may have been an estimated 572 000.
Another review tells us that between 71 and 100% of women decide to terminate a pregnancy with fetal Down syndrome. In countries like Denmark and Iceland the statistics are close to 100%.
Don’t Miss: Aspergers And Stuttering
What Areas Are Covered In This Test
This test for autism in adults is quite extensive in terms of its coverage. During the test, you will be examined against multiple neuro-behavioral symptoms and your individual test responses would be measured against benchmarked patterns that our system has accurately established based on millions of responses collected from our previous test takes.
In general, you would be asked questions of varying difficulties across the following developmental and behavioral areas:
- Observation Skills
- Personal Interest Level Questions
Presence of Experimental Questions in this Test
Every now and then, this Autism test for adults may contain a set of questions that are primarily experimental in nature. Though these questions will not be scored during the Autism quotient assessment, as a test taker, you will not be able to distinguish between these experimental questions and the real ones.
This is done to ensure that we factor in new questions to check response patterns without compromising the integrity or the accuracy of the overall test scores.
Working With An Autism Specialist
Screeners are often given by pediatricians, but if there are red flags that indicate further evaluation would be appropriate, it is best to work with someone who has both experience and expertise in diagnosing children on the autism spectrum. Youre not going to go to a doctor for a heart transplant whos done two or three, right? says Dr. Epstein. Its the same with autism. You want someone whos seen hundreds of kids with all different stripes typical children, intellectually disabled children, autistic children and knows what to look for. Academic and medical centers are often good places to find experienced diagnosticians.
Parents can ask some questions to try to gauge a potential providers experience. For example:
- Whats your training and experience?
- Have you had specific training in assessment of people on the spectrum? How much?
- What do you plan to do as part of this assessment?
- Will you be contacting my childs teacher or pediatrician?
Try to find a practitioner who is able to answer your questions readily and makes you feel comfortable. A clinician who takes your concerns seriously and is experienced in assessing autism spectrum disorder is essential to getting an accurate diagnosis.
- Was this helpful?
Don’t Miss: Does Autism Come From The Mother Or Father
Can You Do Genetic Testing For Autism
Scientists who focus on autism research are increasingly making discoveries to determine whether ASD is a genetic condition . This is leading to more investigations into the potential use of genetic testing for diagnosis.
Genetic testing can be offered to individuals who are suspected of being autistic but these tests dont test for specific autism genes, but rather test syndromic forms of autism such as abnormalities in the chromosomesthere are certain deletions or duplications that occur in the chromosomes found to be related to the expression of autism symptoms .
Current genetic testing for autism diagnosis includes chromosomal microarray analysis, G-banded karyotyping, and fragile X testing. According to DeThorne & Ceman, , postnatal testing is the most common form of genetic testing associated with autism spectrum disorders .
According to Chen, et al. , genetic testing has become a useful tool for people with a history of autism or those showing possible symptoms. Unfortunately, despite the fact, a genetic cause of autism is identified in less than 25% of individuals on the spectrum. Schaefer, G. B. & Mendelsohn indicates a success rate of 6-15% but this includes the range of autism spectrum disorders i.e. pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified , atypical autism, and asperger syndrome.
Genetic testing for autism offers potential benefits such as:
What Happens During An Autism Spectrum Disorder Screening
There is no special test for ASD. Screening usually includes:
- A questionnaire for parents that asks for information about their child’s development and behavior.
- Observation. Your child’s provider will look at how your child plays and interacts with others.
- Tests that ask your child to perform tasks that check their thinking skills and ability to make decisions.
Sometimes a physical problem can cause autism-like symptoms. So screening may also include:
- Blood tests to check for lead poisoning and other disorders
- Hearing tests. A hearing problem can cause problems in language skills and social interaction.
- Genetic tests. These tests look for inherited disorders such as Fragile X syndrome. Fragile X causes intellectual disabilities and symptoms similar to ASD. It most often affects boys.
Read Also: Does Jerry Seinfeld Have Autism
Current Diagnostic Tests For Autism In Adults
There are several tests that can help clinicians diagnose autism in adults.
- ADOS 2 Module 4: The Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule, 2nd Edition, Module 4 is specifically used to diagnose autism in verbally fluent adults. There are several questions regarding common symptoms of autism, including those related to language and communication, reciprocal social interactions, and restricted or repetitive behaviors. The clinician will score each of these areas 1 to 3, and then provide a diagnosis based on the total score.
- ADI-R: This is a survey typically used to diagnose children, based on interviewing their parents. However, some clinicians may use it to diagnose adults with autism, using the same interview questions but instead asking about their childhood experiences.
- 3Di Adult:The Developmental, Dimensional, and Diagnostic Interview Adult Version was developed specifically to help clinicians understand signs of autism in their adult clients. It has shown higher sensitivity and accuracy than other tests.
- AFQ: The Actions and Feelings Questionnaire focuses on differences in motor cognition. This involves how humans process and understand their physical movements, which can help adults relate to the world. This includes social processing, which can help identify adults who are on the autism spectrum.
- RAADS-14: The Ritvo Autism and Asperger Diagnostic Scale-Revised is an 80-question survey to detect autism. The RAADS-14 is the streamlined 14-question version.
Why Does The New Test Analyze Metabolites
Autism spectrum disorder is a developmental disorder with symptoms that generally appear in the first two years of life, according to the National Institute of Mental Health . Scientists dont know the exact cause of ASD, but the NIMH says that genes can act together with influences from the environment to impact development in ways that lead to ASD.
are linked to both genetics as well as environmental factors, both of which are known to play a role in autism, Hahn says. Also, unlike genetics, metabolites concentrations are constantly changing and can better reflect the current status of what is going on in the human body.
Still, Hahn notes that there is no one metabolite that is indicative of ASD. Researchers have to examine a combination of several metabolites to be able to draw conclusions.
Read Also: Life Expectancy Of Someone With Autism
Aspergers Tests For Adults
It may be possible that you or someone you love has aspergers syndrome, but have never been diagnosed. If you suspect that someone in your life has asperger then it may help clarify the situation by having a medical diagnosis done by a psychologist or other medical professional who will run an Aspie test.
Testing For Other Medical Difficulties And Delays
Because other medical conditions sometimes occur with autism, your paediatrician might also do other tests, like a physical examination and history, and a hearing test. These tests:
- check for signs of other conditions that might explain your childs symptoms
- help to identify any other medical conditions that might need treatment.
Its also good for you and the professionals youre working with to know more about your childs strengths and difficulties in thinking and learning. Professionals assess these strengths and difficulties differently depending on your childs age:
- Developmental assessment this is for children under four years old.
- Cognitive assessment this is for children over four years old.
These assessments can help professionals understand whether your childs difficulties are caused by development delays or intellectual disability rather than autism.
Most children will also have a communication andlanguage assessment by a speech pathologist.
Some children might also have their daily living skills, like feeding themselves and dressing, assessed by an occupational therapist.
Also Check: Is Next For Autism A Good Charity
Summary Of Main Results
Given the widespread use of these tests, diagnostic test accuracy data are relatively limited. Overall, only one study was at low risk of bias for all criteria and four studies were known to be at low risk of bias for three or more factors, as assessed by QUADAS2 . Blinding of the reference standard diagnosis was often ignored at the time of index testing, and the index test was sometimes incorporated into the reference standard. These two issues introduce high risk of bias to studies, as they potentially inflate the sensitivity and specificity of the index test. In addition, 29% of included analyses were published by study authors with a potential conflict of interest. Sensitivity analyses for ADOS and CARS indicate that the specificity of tools was susceptible to risk of bias, with lower calculated specificity in studies assessed at low risk of bias. Although studies were, for the most part, applicable to practice in relation to patient selection, for nearly half of the included studies, the reference standard was not, or it was not clear if it was, in keeping with current recommendations for diagnostic practice.
Summary of findingsâ. âDiagnostic accuracy of Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule , Childhood Autism Rating Scale , and Autism Diagnosis Interview Revised for diagnosing autism spectrum disorder in preschool children
Donât Miss: Gestational Diabetes And Autism
Finding Someone Qualified To Evaluate Adults With Asd
Currently, there are relatively few clinicians who specialize in evaluating and treating adults with autism. Nor do we have established criteria to objectively judge such qualifications.
In my opinion, your best bet may be a developmental pediatrician, child psychiatrist or pediatric neurologist who is both experienced in evaluating autism in children and open to seeing older patients. So I would recommend talking to the clinician who diagnosed your child. If she or he does not feel qualified to evaluate an adult, he or she may have a respected colleague who would be.
Otherwise I would recommend contacting an established and respected autism center in your area. Examples include the centers in the Autism Speaks Autism Treatment Network. This will provide you with the assurance that the clinician has agreed to adhere to the centers high standards for care for patients with autism, regardless of age.
Thanks again for your question. I hope this information helps and that youll let us know how youre doing.
You May Like: Visual Cards For Autism
Referral For A Diagnosis
Once your GP or health visitor is convinced of your childs difficulties, your child should be referred for a formal assessment . You may have to wait some time before you actually go for the assessment. In the meantime, your child could be referred to other teams such as a speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, oreducation support services. These professionals might help you to better understand your childâs needs.
Your child should have a multi-disciplinary diagnostic assessment that is, an assessment by a team ofprofessionals. The team might include, for example, a paediatrician, a speech and language therapist and a specialist psychologist.
If your child is referred to an individual professional, its important that they are experienced in diagnosing autism.
Read Also: Are Stuttering And Autism Related
What Is Autism Spectrum Disorder Screening
Autism spectrum disorder is a disorder of the brain that affects a person’s behavior, communication, and social skills. The disorder usually shows up in the first two years of life. ASD is called a “spectrum” disorder because there is a wide range of symptoms. Autism symptoms can range from mild to severe. Some children with ASD may never be able to function without support from parents and caregivers. Others need less support and may eventually live independently.
ASD screening is the first step in diagnosing the disorder. While there is no cure for ASD, early treatment can help reduce autism symptoms and improve quality of life.
Other names: ASD screening
You May Like: Is Level 2 Autism High Functioning
How To Get A Diagnosis
Online screening tools can help parents and caregivers decide whether to seek further specialist help.
If a person wants to confirm an ASD diagnosis either in themselves or a child, they should speak to a doctor. Parents should talk to their pediatrician if they have concerns about their child having ASD.
A doctor may provide additional screening tests. Depending on the results, they may refer people to other specialists.
There is no cure for autism, but many people with the condition can live independent lives.
When a child receives a diagnosis, it is possible to include educational and behavioral interventions. These children with their social and language skills. Examples of treatment approaches include:
- Applied behavior analysis: Uses behavioral reinforcement strategies to encourage certain behaviors. The different techniques include:
- Discrete trial training