Each Character Represents A Different Mental Disorder
A tongue-in-cheek report by the Canadian Medical Association sparked a widely-shared theory that each Winnie the Pooh character symbolizes a certain mental disorder. The theory has been around since at least 2000, when the BBC released an article here. The following is a run-down of each disorder that the characters supposedly have.
It should be noted that this theory, along with similar ones like the SpongeBob seven sins theory, has been debunked . That doesn’t deter fans from finding new evidence to support it.
Mental Disorders of the Winnie the Pooh Characters
Is Christopher Robin On Netflix
Why is Christopher Robin leaving Netflix? As you may know, Netflix struck a deal with Disney back in 2011 that saw all theatrical releases from 2016 to 2019 added to Netflix in the United States. Christopher Robin was included in this deal and arrived on Netflix in both the United States and Canada on March 5th, 2019.
He Feuded With Pg Wodehouse
As a young man, Milne was friends with author P.G. Wodehouse, creator of the unflappable butler Jeeves. The two even joined J.M. Barriethe man behind Peter Panon a celebrity cricket team. However, Wodehouse made a decision during World War II that Milne could not forgive.
Wodehouse had been living in France when the German army swept through. He was taken into custody and sent to live in a civil internment camp. But when the Germans realized just who they’d captured, they took Wodehouse to a luxury hotel in Berlin and asked him to record a series of broadcasts about his internment. Wodehouse, to his later regret, agreed.
In the talks, which were broadcast in 1941, Wodehouse maintained a light, inconsequential tone that didn’t go over well during wartime. Among his harshest critics was Milne, who wrote to the Daily Telegraph: Irresponsibility in what the papers call a licensed humorist can be carried too far; naïveté can be carried too far. Wodehouse has been given a good deal of licence in the past, but I fancy that now his licence will be withdrawn.
The rift continued even after the war ended, with Wodehouse stating at one point: Nobody could be more anxious than myself … that Alan Alexander Milne should trip over a loose bootlace and break his bloody neck.
Also Check: Is Autism A Neurodevelopmental Disorder
Films Movies Westerns Classics Cinematography Reviews
First thoughs:;As Christopher Robins father is walking though his colourful country house gardens with his wife cutting the dead heads off of the pale shaded roses binding around their propertie, you feel a sense satersfaction yet as the female post officer approaches and delivers a letter on that fine morning in Ashdown forest or 100 acre woods you may not be ready;for whats to come;
as his father is running filled with tears he throws a old leather cricket bull in to a clear opening just at the end of the woodland path bang! Sparking Elements fill the corner of the screen with a bull of an flaming fire swiftly the you see people running to the trenches in British First World War army kit as;A. A. Milne ;jumpers on top of dead corpse of other British soldiers the next thing the view knows there is an people of signfcent wealth in freshly ironed suites and silk dresses danceing with Cristal glass of wine but;A. A. Milne, or now known as Blue is feeling the effects of war the war to end all wars the war you do not talk about, because if it is not talked about it is ;forgotten thus ;not a problem as he dances with his wife his friend steps up .
The film has its emotional journeys of happiness, sadness and proudness the key emotion with in this film is morale when a nation is brought to depression sometimes all it takes is childs happiness to brightening it up a bit .
What Are The Disorders Of Winnie The Pooh
Winnie the pooh has a compulsive eating disorder and a repetitive counting behaviour that could suggest Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder . It is believed he could have ADHD and also some people question whether Pooh may over-time suffer from Tourettes syndrome. However, to be certain we would need to do a thorough assessment and obtain more information.
Read Also: When Did Autism First Start
A A Milnes Struggle With Ptsd
When A. A. Milne returned from France after the First World War, he, like many survivors of the conflict, had changed.
It is OK to be a Tigger, or a dreamer like Pooh.
In upcoming film Goodbye Christopher Robin, the author is portrayed as someone blighted by visions of fallen comrades as he suffers from PTSD even if the condition hadnt been recognised in those days.
In a recent interview with Entertainment Weekly,;actor Domnhall Gleeson who plays Milne in the biopic explained that Eeyore is like an extension of the writers real-life pain.
He had his dark sides to him where he would go into himself. He could be quite a loner.
He basically bundled all those bad feelings up and kind of gave them to the world in the form of Eeyore.
In his autobiography Its Too Late Now, Milne barely acknowledges the war, which played such a key part in his life.
Perhaps the books of Winnie the Pooh were his way of conveying an inner turmoil.
Perhaps Dr Shea and her team werent so far off the mark after all.
Why Is Eeyore Depressed
In the episode Winnie-the-Pooh and a Day for Eeyore, the gang discovers Eeyore is particularly sad because no one remembered his birthday. Distraught by this oversight, Pooh and Piglet rush home to get gifts for their friend. Pooh tries to give Eeyore a pot of honey but ends up eating it on his way to Eeyores house.
You May Like: How Do You Know If You Have An Autistic Child
Why Is Winnie The Pooh Important
In a world shaken by war, Winnie-the-Pooh offered innocence, simplicity and a happy place to escape. … As well as being a much-needed tonic for the country, the collection also introduced the first generation of children to what is now, arguably, the most famous bear in the world: Winnie-the-Pooh.
Which Winnie The Pooh Character Are You
Although the;myth;that A.A. Milne created Winnie the Pooh to reflect different mental health conditions has been debunked. It doesnt change the fact people can see different mental health conditions in each of the characters. Thus, I thought itd be a nice change of pace to see, Which Winnie The Pooh Character Are You?.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, Ill earn a commission, at no additional cost to you. Read my full disclosure here.
Recommended Reading: Is Asperger Syndrome A Type Of Autism
A Lovely Example For Children
Dr Shea admits that she knew nothing of A. A. Milnes own battle with mental illness when she compiled her colleagues thoughts on his beloved characters.
But regardless of their neuroses and issues, she believes that the loving interaction between the characters of 100 Acre Wood can act as a positive example to children on how to treat others in spite of their flaws, be that hyperactivity, low mood or anxiety.
More than anything, the key to the books are their tone of love and acceptance and unspoken forgiveness in the Hundred Acre Wood.
The stories provide lovely examples of how humans should behave.
Dr Shea believes that if a child living with a mental illness can identify with one of Milnes characters this can only be a good thing.
It can normalise the experience, especially because the characters do live in such harmony.
It is OK to be a Tigger, or a dreamer like Pooh.
Goodbye Christopher Robin is released in UK cinemas this Friday
More from i:
Why Is The Donkey In Winnie The Pooh Sad
In the episode Winnie-the-Pooh and a Day for Eeyore, the gang discovers Eeyore is particularly sad because no one remembered his birthday. Distraught by this oversight, Pooh and Piglet rush home to get gifts for their friend. Pooh tries to give Eeyore a pot of honey but ends up eating it on his way to Eeyores house.
You May Like: How To Tell If Your Parent Is Autistic
Why Is This Important
Living with PTSD, or with someone who is contending with PTSD, is not always easy. The aftermath of trauma does not happen in a vacuum and reverberates through the fabric of families and the community as a whole. Winnie and friends normalize some of that impact. They are cute and fluffy, kind and caring, and each has its own quirks. They remind us that irritability does not mean a lack of kindness, and that fear and anxiety may be inconvenient sometimes, but they are something that we experience, not something that defines our essence.
A. A. Milne likely found a creative way of talking about his struggles and those of many other individuals affected by trauma. He did this in a way that elicits compassion, a sense of community, and even laughter. Unconsciously, trauma overwhelms us and we may want to shut down or turn the other way, in order to not look at it. But when we do not look at it, it remains unprocessed within us, often impacting our feelings, behaviors, and relationships without us realizing it. We may also find ourselves unable to offer support to loved ones who are dealing with their own emotional burden. In breaking down the full picture of PTSD into smaller, more easily digestible characters, Milne allows us to see them as coexisting with all the other positive characteristics in our personalities, that may sometimes get lost or unnoticed when we are struggling.
Head over to Part Two, in which the animals of the Hundred Acre Wood await!
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
The hyperactive tiger is unable to control his hyperactivity. Although he is a social magnet amongst the characters, he is in fact a bad role model as he is so impulsive.
There is a possibility Tigger also suffers from a substance abuse problem, this is indicated by him being prepared to try;any substance or matter that comes along his path.
You May Like: How To Tell If Your Teenager Is Autistic
Why Use This Test
1. Free. This free online Pooh Pathology Test is delivered to you free of charge and will allow you to obtain your match on one of seven characters from A.A. Milnes beloved tales.
2. Unique. While there are other Winnie the Pooh tests out there, this test utilizes a unique framework by pairing the insights of professors and M.D.s with the characters known from the Hundred Acre Wood.
3. Statistical controls. Test scores are logged into an anonymized database. Statistical analysis of the test is conducted to ensure maximum accuracy and validity of the test scores.
4. Made by professionals. The authors of this free online test are certified in the use of numerous personality tests and have worked professionally with personality typology, as well as corporate, personality, and IQ testing.
This test is also available in the following languages:
Tigger Bounces Between Hyperactivity And Impulsivity
Tigger’s diagnosis is a no-brainer. The fanciful tiger can’t hold still for a moment. He’s a classic case of ADHD, with an emphasis on the H:;hyperactivity. He is super active even when he clearly needs rest.
Tigger also exhibits poor impulse control, bouncing where he isn’t wanted, assuming everyone around him wants to be similarly engaged in whatever it is he is doing.
Also Check: What Age Does Autism Appear
Winnie The Pooh Actually Existed
Milne didn’t encounter a real bear, accompanied by a group of animal friends, wandering around the Hundred Acre Wood, but almost all of the characters in his books had real-life counterparts. Christopher Robin, Pooh’s human companion, was named after Milne’s own son, Christopher Robin Milne . Winnie the Pooh was Christopher’s teddy bear.
Christopher Milne also played with a stuffed piglet, a tiger, a pair of kangaroos and a downtrodden donkey . And the Hundred Acre Wood closely resembles Ashdown Forest, where the Milnes had a nearby home.
Today the original toys that inspired Milne can still be seen at the New York Public Library.
The Disorders Of Characters In Winnie The Pooh
The fan theory The Disorders of Characters in Winnie the Pooh was conceived by The Canadian Medical Association.
- Winnie the Pooh has an eating disorder. He is addicted to Honey. He is also impulsive and obsessive when it comes to Honey.
- Piglet has Anxiety or Generalized Anxiety Disorder. He is always nervous or scared. He stutters because he could have experienced an incident where his self esteem was weakened.
- Eeyore has Depression because he is always sad.
- Owl has Dyslexia and Short Term Memory Loss because he often misspells and misreads words, forgets things after he says them, and has trouble recalling information.
- Tigger has ADHD, or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and Bipolar Disorder because he cannot sit still and rapidly switches moods.
- Rabbit has OCD or Obsessive Compulsive Disorder because he is extremely orderly.
- Kanga has Social Anxiety Disorder because she is extremely overprotective of Roo.
- Christopher Robin has Schizophrenia because his friends appear depending on his mood.
Also Check: How To Care For Autistic Child
Which Pooh Character Am I
I think Im closest to being Eeyore. Thats because Ive suffered from depression almost my entire life and exist in an almost permanent state of melancholy. However, I can still experience fleeting bouts of joy, unlike Eeyore. Ive also had issues with self-harming and suicide, unlike Eeyore.
I also have a splash of Piglet in me, because I too suffer from an anxiety disorder, just not;generalised anxiety. Unlike Piglet, my worries arent indiscriminate, my anxiety disorders have fixed fears. I suffer from;social anxietyand agoraphobia;.
Although in the back of my mind I often have a more Piglet orientated anxiety, accept I can control that.
Lastly, I obviously have a dash of Owl in me too, thanks to my;dyslexia. I found lots of ways to try and hide my issues with spelling and reading. Much like how Owl talk hes way out of his secret being found out, I would write my way around the words I couldnt spell. This would make my sentences and course work at school much longer than they needed to be as I used a series of simpler words that could have been easily replaced by one word that I knew, but couldnt spell. It was a huge pain in the rear when doing exams.
If youre interested in finding out more about my;dyslexia, you can do so;here;and;here.
Lastly, if youd like to support my blog then you can make a donation of any size below also. Until next time,;Un
Why Does Winnie The Pooh Have Adhd
Winnie the Pooh alongside Tigger may have ADHD and for the first, it seems to display the classic behaviours of Inattentive ADD. It is believed that the inattentive ADD suffer from brain fog just like Winnie the Pooh. He is very lovable and kind but it is also inattentive, sluggish and slow-moving. It is suggested that he could also be easily distracted, having a short attention span towards tasks that are not interesting or perceived as hard.
Read Also: How To Make A Visual Schedule For Autism
Winnie The Pooh Mental Disorders
In this guide, we will discuss Winnie the pooh mental disorders but without considering them a final diagnosis for each character since there is a lack of information to diagnose the characters from Winnie the Pooh. We might be familiar with the story and its characters but here we will take a look at them through a different perspective but dont consider the diagnostic categories as final.
What Are The Diagnosed Disorders
Winnie the Pooh: An eating disorder, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder;, meaning it is very hard to focus he also has impulsivity with obsessive fixations.
Piglet: Generalized Anxiety Disorder. The theory states that he may have suffered from an injury that crippled his self-esteem, and that his stuttering problem most likely developed from said injury.
Owl: Dyslexia and Short-Term Memory Loss. Even though hes shown as being exceptionally bright, its shown that he has trouble reading. An example would be in Poohs Grand Adventure when he mistook the word school for skull. Also Owl tends to forget things as quickly as he says them.
Tigger: ADHD. Tigger is always seen bouncing and can never stay in one place for a long period of time.
Kanga: Social Anxiety Disorder. She is very overprotective of her son, and she would never let her son make his own decisions because of her overprotectiveness.
Roo: Autism. He lacks awareness of danger and has an attachment to sitting in his mothers pouch.
Rabbit: Obsessive compulsive disorder . He is very orderly and obsessive, and the theory also questions his sexual orientation due to his feminine behavior.
Eeyore: Depressive Disorder. He always has a bleak outlook on life, and never feels any positive emotions like happiness and excitement.
Christopher Robin: Schizophrenia. It is believed that all the characters from above are manifested depending on Christophers mood.
Also Check: How To Work With Kids With Autism
What Mental Health Conditions Are Represented By Winnie The Pooh Characters
Though the paper is clearly a send-up, in analyzing Milnes famous Winnie the Pooh characters, Shea and her colleagues highlighted the very real need for support and awareness of our own mental wellbeing, as well as to the health of those around us.
For the curious, here are the researchers fictional character mental health diagnoses:
- Winnie-the-Pooh Attention Deficit Hyper-Activity Disorder and Obsessive Compulsive Disorder , due to his fixation on honey and repetitive counting
- Piglet Generalized Anxiety Disorder
- Rabbit Narcissism
- Eyeore Dysthymic Disorder
- Owl Dyslexia
- Christopher Robin No diagnosable disorder, though Christopher lacks parental supervision and spends most of his time talking to animals
- Tigger ADHD
- Kanga Social Anxiety Disorder
- Roo Autism
Like many things that take on a life of their own on the internet and social media, some of these were suggested by others in addition to the original paper.